Object added in Local view don't update till you go out of it
I never notice, but looks like the object you build while you are in the Local view, despite being added to the outiner, (and so to the scene as well) they don't appear in the Global view till you go out from the local View.
At least this is what happens in 2.78 version.
If you open another window, you can examine the scene that is being rendered:
Eyes are missing, and maybe the planes that are providing light to the scene...all objects that you have probably built while you was in Local view without ever going out.
Those are not rendered because they are in a limbo, trapped in the Local view waiting to be released. That's where the difference cames from.
You can see how the cube added in the image sequence below is not in the Global till I go out from Local view.
I don't kown if this is a feature or a little bug.