4
$\begingroup$

I recently installed Filmic color and its awesome.

My issue is that I use Blender to create and bake textures for an external program.

When you bake an image with Filmic installed it actually creates two images on the UV (This is under the Color Space option)

Here are both UVs

sRBG EOTF

sRPG EOTF

And Filmic Log

Filmic Log

My main issue is whenever I do "Save as Image" it only exports the sRBG layer and I can not figure out how to export just the Filmic Log layer as an image. I have tried saving JPG, TGA, PNG and so on and it always exports only the sRPG layer.

Either this is a bug or it something I am missing in the settings.

Can someone help me or have any ideas?

Thank you!

$\endgroup$
3
$\begingroup$

By changing color space you don't actually change the image itself but rather the view of it, same image seen differently.
If you want to bake the view in the texture you need to check save as render when you save your image.
fresnel_f0_80%_custom

But what is it for? Will your texture will be lighted in the other program? If it's the case it's isn't a good aproach, better bake it as an Albedo. The transfer fonction of the filmic from scene referred data to display referred data must be the last operation on the image. It means that if your texture will be light after Blender you would need filmic in the other software.

EDIT1

You're not in the right place to manage color, here it's just the color space of the texture when you look at it.
To save your image with the right look you must :

-Go in the scene tab
-Under color management set display device to sRGB, view to Filmic Log, and look choose the one you want.
-After that you can save your image.

color_management

EDIT2

I think I have the point now, you are confused by what happens in the image editor. When you rendered your texture and saved it, you already baked the filmic look in the texture, then you load the texture in the image editor and change the color space to filmic.
What is happening in image editor when you change the color spaces to Filmic is that it bring back the transformation to linear (only if you baked your image with filmic).

The steps you made:

  1. Linear scene referred datas (raw render) to BT.709/Filmic Log color space (saved image)
  2. BT.709/Filmic Log back to linear scene referred data.
    Consider the image color space in the image editor a invertor of thansformation curves.

Like this you can encode a linear scene referred data (that you can normally only export in EXR 32bit) in a 8/16bit image (with the possibility to decode back to linear scene referred data) exept for the desaturation part of the Filmic. I think to decode back without loss you'll need 16bit image.

So for your need, bake your image with the Filmic (like I said in the Edit1 part), then put it in your other software (emission shader or so, strength to 1) you're done.

And if you want to see a texture in image editor let it by default unless you know why you change it. In your case you must set it to sRGB EOTF.

|improve this answer|||||
$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Hi, save as render changes nothing (tried it before) So you are saying I am not actually changing the image, just the filter applied in the UV image window? That is a bummer. I bring these models into Secondlife, which technically has a lighting system of it's own, but it sucks and it so much better to bake the lighting and shadows. I can achieve a look using regular lighting tricks in Blender, I was just hoping to take advantage of Filmic to make it more natural without blowing out my textures. I understand the limitations of Filmic since the look can't actually be baked? $\endgroup$ – Mike Johnson Feb 23 '17 at 17:47
  • $\begingroup$ Of course you can save your image with the filmic LUT applied. I'll edit my answer to explain how to do it. $\endgroup$ – Mareck Feb 23 '17 at 23:02
  • $\begingroup$ Hi there. This is already my settings. Don't get me wrong... I think you are awesome for responding. Here I will create a link to IMGUR Here are my scenic settings And here is the end result exporting image My texture Do you get different results? $\endgroup$ – Mike Johnson Feb 24 '17 at 23:35
  • $\begingroup$ I'm close to have a proper answer, but I want it to not introduce mistake, so I'm verifing a point. $\endgroup$ – Mareck Feb 25 '17 at 15:00

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.