0
$\begingroup$

I need to make curving concave and convex meshes, while at the same time, expressing the mesh data as only quads. (Quad meshes work well with subdivision, smooth shading, and bevel, but triangular or n-gonal meshes don't work with all 3.)

The nature of being both concave and convex thwarts making quads going completely vertically or horizontally and similarly messes with the almighty grid fill. I had no luck converting this mesh from a filled 2d curve, since the curve is filled with triangles that cause shading artifacts. So I tried manual work, revealing it is indeed impossible to fill with quads in a purely vertices/horizontal manner. An n-gon fill doesn't work, and the last image shows that grid fill has issues even at its best. I also tried smoothing vertices on all methods, and it got the grid fill method pretty close.

I could use workarounds, like using flat shading on the flat side of the axe with an autosmooth modifier, but I want subdivision and smooth shading.

(When extruded out) how can I fill this mesh in a way that doesn't cause smooth shading artifacts?

picture of filled axe head Filled from 2d curve vertical bars with unfortunate triangulation necessary manual shading artifacts simple n-gon fill partially overlapping quads stretched across parts of the axe

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ This is quite complex case for grid fill to work out of the box. You could fill that ugly Ngon for beginning, inset it a bit and get good shading around edges. After that I think you will still need to figure out a way to get rid of that Ngon - again GridFill or joining verts located opposite to each other with J. $\endgroup$ – Mr Zak Sep 11 '16 at 9:34
  • $\begingroup$ I think that quad-only property is not enough to ensure good subsurface and bevel: you'll have to keep an eye on edgeflows too. Probably retopology is the best way to approach this task. $\endgroup$ – Carlo Sep 11 '16 at 9:53
2
$\begingroup$

Axe

You should retopolgize this mesh. It is pretty simple with method I will present (if this kind a mesh will suite you).

  1. First of all you should make a plane and position it at the bottom of the blade.

  2. Then extrude it all the way up.

  3. Select loop and extrude to the end of axe scaling down each loop.

This gif shows the retopo flow:

retopo

If you need more detailed description, let me know in comment what do you need.

Edit:

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Hmm. You mean I should make a plane in edit mode with the vertices active, right? I made one out of the three vertices at the bottom of the axe (the first face your gif highlights). I understand step 3 fully, but I wasn't able to get a uniform appearance by extruding that plane. At least, not one that curves like all the faces you have on the edge of the axe. I'm new to retopology. $\endgroup$ – person27 Sep 11 '16 at 15:43
  • $\begingroup$ Make a plane in object mode, then go to edit mode and extrude edges of this plane. Gif is showing only edge flow of the mesh, not actual steps. $\endgroup$ – cgslav Sep 11 '16 at 15:45
  • $\begingroup$ top-down, orthographic view I'm assuming. I'll give it a shot. I'm guessing you had to adjust the edges of the first face as you extruded more from it so that the faces were curving properly. $\endgroup$ – person27 Sep 11 '16 at 15:46
  • $\begingroup$ I'm using front ortho. Yes, you need to set vertices of the first plane as shown in the gif, kind a diamond look, then select right-top edge and start extruding. When you make the blade, select left edge loop (alt + right click) and extrude this to the left. $\endgroup$ – cgslav Sep 11 '16 at 15:49
  • $\begingroup$ Set the image to pivot/scale around the 3d cursor to avoid this (imgur.com/nT90A0u). Use ctrl + shift + alt + S to shear to match the nearby vertices as best as possible. I got it :) $\endgroup$ – person27 Sep 11 '16 at 16:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.