1
$\begingroup$

enter image description here

Primary

I have a single mesh named legs. Armature modifier with automatics weights is used. Part of the glove has correct weights. The band of the glove does not have correct weights. What action should I take?

Weights of the glove. The appropriate group is selected.

Secondary

Can't seem to figure this one out. I have objects that are joined to others, such as the straps on the arms or the bottom of gloves, and with the default Automatic Weight Paints, they don't get painted and just stay in place. No matter how little or much I paint them, they move, but out of sync. I've tried messing with the Vertex Groups as well - adding the objects to their own group - but can't that to work properly either. Any suggestions?

Thanks

This is the issue I'm referring to... The strap at the bottom of the glove just won't move with the arm/hand. And yet the one in green does with Weight Paints.

enter image description here

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Please see a tutorial on weight painting to understand basic concepts. youtube.com/watch?v=rkT92aoMpP0 $\endgroup$ – atomicbezierslinger Nov 29 '18 at 6:53
  • $\begingroup$ Suggestion. On the same video website in the comment above, please see one or more intermediate to advanced videos on Blender Weight Painting . Cumulative time of 88 minutes. Understand some portion, not all, of complex weight painting. Some portion will remain in your subconscious and can be used in the future. $\endgroup$ – atomicbezierslinger Nov 29 '18 at 16:44
0
$\begingroup$

Your can choose from a few different options to improve your situation.

Option 01 Copy Vertex weights in Edit Mode

The correct vertex group for the particular band is selected in the UI from the vertex list in the Mesh Panel, as seen in the image below. Know the band is distant from Bone and currently not attached to body of glove. The disconnected band is moved .5 Y axis units for visibility. The band is selected. A Single vertex is selected on the perimeter of glove as shown by yellow arrow. The weights of this single vertex could be cleaned up, not shown here. The Vertex Copy weights button is clicked. Weights are changed. Disconnected band is moved -.5 Y axis units. Repeat on other side.

This will improve the immediate problem and assist your understanding. Improvement is the goal here and a light discussion of weight assignment. Not 100% physical realism. If I had more time I would examine and clean up the source weights. Hopefully there will be more steps to improve the model outside this question. Currently the glove can intersect and pass through the organic skin portion of the mesh, which is not high physics realism. Answer time is finite. In the little experiments I did, this gave the best result in some small amount of time. Of course the whole mesh could be painted by hand and other controls added, with no automatic weights. More realism would come with larger time consumption.

Other problems will remain which may require a new question.

enter image description here

Copy Vertex Weight Image above. Note arrow showing single source vertex of the well behaved body of glove.


Option 02. Modify Mesh and Armature Parent again. Exercise for the OP

  • Connect the glove band to the the body of the glove. The band is distant from the bone. It is not connected to the body of the glove by vertices. Vertex connectivity is taken into account for some automatic weights. Distance to Bone is taken into account. The details are not discussed here. Then parent to armature again and test.

There could be an argument to consider the glove as very different than the human skin of the mesh. Some might say the glove is like clothing and should be a separate mesh.


Option 03. More Weight Paint .. Weight Assignment.

Please paint/inspect again the band of your glove. Please improve any weight paint results you see below. 2 Options.

  • Use Weight Paint mode
  • Edit Mode. Select the band only. Select the named group. Assign a weight of 1.0 which is full weight.

Band is not yet painted.

enter image description here

In the image above. We see above we see your model. The body of the glove is painted. The band of the glove has zero weights. In weight paint mode please paint the band. See how the correct group is selected before we paint. Well there are possible two correct groups as candidates.

Weight Painted Band in the Correct group.

enter image description here

Painting of band has begun. Red color. In edit mode of the mesh I selected the band prior to my weight painting.

The topic of weight painting can be mastered. This short answer will not be equivalent to a video weight painting tutorial.

Direct assignment to group in edit mode of mesh.

enter image description here

Weight assignment. See the arrow. Image above.

enter image description here

Showing weight in edit mode of mesh. See arrow. Image above.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ You, sir, are a saint! Thank you SO much for this. Much appreciated. :D I've also learnt something new - I had no idea you could apply weights/paint it in Edit Mode. That should make things a bit easier as well. $\endgroup$ – DustyShinigami Nov 29 '18 at 16:09
  • $\begingroup$ Only Dirty Dog Donald is the Saint some would say. Some people in certain countries think that way. $\endgroup$ – atomicbezierslinger Nov 29 '18 at 16:47
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks for the update on your original post. That's also invaluable advice and taught me a little something extra. :) $\endgroup$ – DustyShinigami Nov 29 '18 at 17:43

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.